Events

Events

Talking Point

Analysis

Photo

Video

Islam

Links

Important

Chat

Archive

.

Language

English

Türkçe

Русский

Mirrors 

argun.org

dagestan.org

Mail

Hotmail

Yahoo

Dotexpres

UsaNet


Tuesday, 23, October 2001

Whether Ilya Muromets was participant of Jihad?

It is not paradoxical, but Russian culture has Islamic roots.

It is not paradoxical, but Russian culture has Islamic roots in imperial time, especially at the end of XIX century. This fact was meaningfully deformed and ignored. The reasons to understand it is not difficult: long-term Russian-Turk opposition and Germanism of Russian intellectuals. On inertia, this policy was adapted by Soviet and post-Soviet epoch. However, we shall look at things soberly.

To all Russians is known fantastic image of the dairy rivers, but one will guess very little, that it goes back to a paradise source mentioned in the Holy Quran (Surah «Muhammad», ayat 15). To all is known Russian expression «to be on the top of the seventh sky with happiness», but very few people know, that it corresponds to the Muslim doctrine about seven heavens created by Allah (Surah Talaq «Divorce»: 65, ayat 12). To all is known Russian’s custom to spit through the left shoulder, but very few people know its meaning. Under the Muslim interpretation, God for each person has allocated two angels who stand accordingly on right and left shoulders and writes the good acts and the other writes evil.

Many examples can be put forward, but the case with epic heroes is especially interesting. In Russian humanity science, this image actively started to be developed since second half of XIX century. Russian historians and specialists in folklore were completely not objective. The official order and modern trends have resulted to that in an image of heroes, we see faster stereotypes of XIX century, than real prototypes of epics. Heroes appear those loyal frontier guards (known picture of Vasnetosov «Three Bogatyrs»), romantic heroes.

But we will address to texts of epics. Words of «Hero» and «Cossack» in them are used as synonyms. Both terms are of Turkism (batyr and the Kazakh). Actions of epics occur not in wood, where usually settled Slavs (not casually their language transfers various semantic shades of a word «wood» - a grove, a thicket, a pine forest, a jungle), and in the Eurasian steppes. The known hero Ilya (Ilyas) is born in settlement with typically not Slavic name Karacharovo. In Turkish languages «kara» specifies black color (Kara Kum - black sand, Карадаг - black mountain). However, we shall not abuse searches of sources of powerful movement in this or that ethnic environment. We shall try to reply: what the heroes do for heroes? All of them were warriors: Ilyas from Karacharov, Alesha Popovich (ibn Mullah) and Dobrynia Nikitich. They battle with pagans. Who are those pagans? And this word is not Slavic, and then it is necessary to search for its sources in other languages. 

In English pagan designates disbeliever. But it is necessary to search for sources of this word not in the German languages, and in Latin where paganus means countryman. There is no contradiction in the assumption, that the word «pagan» has got in Slavic and German languages from Latin similar to others. Why it has got frankly negative sense? Obviously when the Gospel was granted to the prophet Jesus Christ (peace be upon him!), paganism’s misbelieves for long time kept in the conservative rural environment. Then the word «pagan» is synonym of word «kafir» (disbeliever), and «pogan» - kufr (disbelief). In that case, epic heroes were participants of holy war with disbelief, i.e. jihad. Means, in essence, they were mujahideen. Really, that speaks Ilyas Dobryne in the epic «Michaelo Potik»: «And look, you, Dobrynia, for blue sea, reproach you, languages there are misbelieving», i.e. battle with kafirs.

Certainly, Slavophile and national (both official, and alternative) ideologies possess fixing agents and interpreters of epics, therefore, in epics, we see, a lot of contradicting factors to true belief. However, the fact remains the fact, despite of all ambiguity, original essence of a hero was jihad.

In the end, I shall bring two identical paragraphs from the epic and the Holy Quran. 
«As two Russian - de struggle, it is necessary to talk, and Russian with disbelief, it is necessary to extend help to them, and two non-Russian, it is necessary to go away» (Duel of Danube Ivanovich with Dobrynya Nikitich).
«And if two parties or groups among the believers fall to fighting, then make peace between them both, but if one of them rebels against the other, then fight you (all) against the one that which rebels till it complies with the Command of Allâh» (Surah al-Hujurat: 49, ayat: 9). Russian heroes were mujahideen. At least, this version does not meet contradictions in historian-cultural context and explains many unclear facts.

Alexey Ivanenko, specially for Kavkaz-Center

Back to top ^^



Also in this section: 

  Whether Ilya Muromets
   was participant of Jihad?

  Future of the captured
   lieutenant colonel is yet not
   clear
  Shevardnadze explained all
   that happened in Abkhazia

  Solzhenitsyn will be
   deprived of Nobel Prize

  Amin means «Reliable»

  Chechens exchange, and
   Russian purchase

  Shanghai in the siege
  Yerevan initiates
   «Armenian problem» in
   Georgia

  War flares up in Southern
   Caucasus


Events ] Talking Point ] Analysis ] Photo ] Video ] Islam ] Links ] Important ] Chat Archive


Copyright © 1999-2001.  "Kavkaz-Center"  News Agency
The reprint without prior permission is violation of international legislation of the Webmaster:
webmaster@kavkaz.org
The publication of authors may not coincide with ideas of edition of the site "Kavkaz-Center"